Chetan Bhagat’s letter to Kashmiri youth will leave you thinking!

Dear Kashmiri friends (the ones who don’t like India),

I write in this open forum because something terrible is happening in the Kashmir Valley. The recent events at NIT Srinagar only brought the situation to national attention. Some students burst crackers when India lost the T20 semi-final. Many students were beaten for raising the Indian flag. Thereafter, bloody clashes have broken out in north Kashmir.

I understand that there is little pro-India sentiment amongst locals in the Kashmir Valley. Many would rather the Valley be on its own, some wouldn’t even mind being with Pakistan. I will not judge you. Despite being a patriotic Indian, i won’t hold it against you if you hate India. You must and do have your reasons for it.

However, allow me to present another point of view. Allow me to tell you how your future will be best, on a practical basis, if the Kashmir Valley integrates and assimilates with India. This is not an emotional, political or historical argument. It is simply more rational for people in the Kashmir Valley who seek a better future to do it with India.

Sure, the experts will jump on me now. Experts who have made the Kashmir problem their fiefdom. However, if the problem were indeed solved, how will these people stay relevant? Hence, they always attack any solution with their elitist ‘this is too complicated an issue’ stance. They love complicated. It gives them another conference to attend. You suffer with complicated, as the problem never gets solved.

The issue is complicated for sure. For those who don’t know the Kashmir issue, here it is in a nutshell. India became independent. Princely states were assimilated. Jammu & Kashmir didn’t accede. Pakistan attacked Kashmir, took half of it (and still controls it). Kashmir’s ruler called India for help. In return for help J&K became part of India, but with riders.

J&K would have its own constitution, have more political independence than other states, while the Centre would handle defence, foreign affairs and communications. In theory, it was a good solution, a sort of one country, two systems approach. In reality, it never worked.

Read also : Imagining an Independent Kashmir: Decoding a Disaster

Instead of two parents as planned, J&K became nobody’s child and an orphan. Pakistan took advantage and used the common factor of Islam to start a militant movement. The Indian army tried to control it. However, it is difficult to control terrorism that co-exists with a civilian population (case in point: even the world’s superpowers appear unable to control Islamic State).

Hence the Indian army, and India, only got a bad name in the Valley. Thus the ‘we hate India’ slogans and perennially unsolved Kashmir problem.

The question is, what is a Kashmiri youth to do now? First, it is important for everyone, not just Kashmiris, to understand the area and people involved. The J&K map we see in Indian textbooks is far from what exists on the ground. Half of what we see in the map is taken over by Pakistan and China. Even though India may claim it, unless we are okay with heavy civilian casualties (which we are not), we will never get it.

Hence, let’s just focus on the half under Indian control, which can be divided into three areas: Ladakh, Jammu and the Valley. Most of the trouble is in the Kashmir Valley. This is only around 7% of the area Indians see on the J&K map and approximates the size of Manipur. In terms of people it is 7 million, roughly the population of Chennai.

The terrain is rugged and the area is completely landlocked. Even if we were to indulge the argument that India is a terrible country and so Kashmir Valley should be on its own, can you really build a sustainable country out of it? It will be a tiny stub in a troubled area, abused by both India and Pakistan. With no real economy and extreme dependence on its giant neighbours, it risks becoming a cesspool of terrorism, drugs and smuggling.

There is also a risk of its being taken over by fundamentalist Islamic forces. It is unlikely anybody from outside would invest money in such a dangerous place. There would be no jobs and no safety. Would you want to live there? Ditto if it joins Pakistan. India is seen as a major emerging market economy. Pakistan is not even seen as a real economy.

Another issue is women’s rights. Half of the Valley’s people are women. Given the hold of fundamentalist Islam, their rights would be curbed under both the independence and Pakistan options. This half of the population would be better off with India. Or do what women want not matter?

If you are Kashmiri and care for Kashmir, the best thing you can do is to integrate with India. Your population size is small, only 7 million. It is not unthinkable to unite them and create a group of people that talks real business with the Indian government. Your local politician won’t talk assimilation, as he or she would rather hold more power than a typical state government in India. However, for you, the youth, the best bet is to make the Valley truly part of India.

The rest of India should not ask for the removal of Article 370. The 7 million people in the Valley should. Kashmiri Pandits who were made to leave the Valley need to be brought back. Terrorism is no solution, nor revenge and retribution for Indian atrocities. Terrorism is only going to harm people in the Valley most.

So, it is youth in the Valley who have to now start a movement to really solve this problem. Get rid of Article 370. It is not empowering Kashmir. It is only empowering your local politicians, who frankly can do nothing for you without Indian integration.

Don’t blame the Indian army. It has the tough job of weeding out terrorists from a civilian population which is almost impossible without collateral damage, terrible as that might be. However, blame those truly responsible, the Pakistani army, the local leaders who exploited the situation and the experts who did nothing for you.

Don’t burst crackers when India loses. Don’t feel good when India fails.

Because if India fails, you will fail too.

Jai Hind. Jai Kashmir.


 

Courtesy

DISCLAIMER : Views expressed above are the author’s own.

88 Comments on this Post

  1. Chetan Baghat is one mistake among three mistake of modern times.

    Reply
    • LiveinPeace

      Dear Kashmiris,

      Ask one simple question about your origin. Your ancestors invaded India in a barbaric way killing Hindus, Buddhists and slowly become majority in the valley. Are you not shameful to claim the land which is not yours. Kashmir has got thousands of year history including that of sage kashyapa from him the name kashmir is inspired with. The real oppression has happened by you people who are outsiders. I think if you want azadi from us then better test your DNA and go to your country of origin and live peacefully with taliban/IS/Al-qaeda. Please leave us to live in peace or else be one among us without cribbing in the name of ISLAM. As chetan pointed out rightly, your future is bright with India and not with Pakistan. If at all you go with Pakistan you will become something lile earlier Bangaldesh or Balochistan. Please pakistanis will not give you special treatment. think if you can…..

      Reply
    • Bramhastra

      Remind the world who Sikandar Butshikan was and what he did to the original settlers of Kashmir.. There was NOT a single Muslim there. He murdered, pillaged, killed and converted with wanton… but muslims being muslims quickly forget that… Remind the world what YOU did to the remaining sikhs and Hindus? Now you claim that land is yours? really? It was never yours… Invaders will always be invaders.. it does not matter when they came.

      Reply
  2. This letter is at par with his books. #bullshit

    Reply
  3. After reading these sugar coated words,i will put a simple question how kashmiris sustained before india got independence and what is the logic that we are 7% population of total india,does it give you license to be oppressor and because we are tiny geographically i will give you so many nations,which are not at par to kashmir,neither in size nor in terms of population.

    Reply
    • correct your facts kasmiri are less than 2% of indian poulation and how kashmir become muslim majority every one know, so do not make fool to yourself because are are not.

      Reply
    • dear majeed ,you all well know ,kashmir is not going to be independent ,kashmir is the most autonomous state of india .full integration with india is your best bet , if not live like this .be pragmatic my friend .pakistan cant even save their own asses ,how can they save yours .its upto u to decide .and trust me ,u cant find a country like india to live in .we have our differences but we also know how to live with differences .rest is your own will.

      Reply
    • 1. As he told, part if J&K is with pakistan and China. In the rest, Jammu and Ladakh people are not really looking forward for independence from India. so the rest is only the Kashmir valley – now with India.
      2. Give me any landlocked, so small country (that too in a conflict ridden area) that is happy.

      Reply
    • Bramhastra

      You are the oppressor!! Not only in Kashmir but all over the world… Terrorism started with you in Kashmir.. Indian Army did not invite itself there. Now that you are being beaten back, you claim oppression? Nice.. the victim attitude is playing out nicely.. just like everywhere else in the world.. they commit terrorism and when beaten back they claim victim hood.. classical trait of a muslim.. so predictable…
      ———-
      Remind the world who Sikandar Butshikan was and what he did to the original settlers of Kashmir.. There was NOT a single Muslim there. He murdered, pillaged, killed and converted with wanton… but muslims being muslims quickly forget that… Remind the world what YOU did to the remaining sikhs and Hindus? Now you claim that land is yours? really? It was never yours… Invaders will always be invaders.. it does not matter when they came.

      Reply
  4. Sale aazad to ho ab chahiye moot wo mil rahi hai

    Reply
  5. Joke of the day……lol hv guts to repate loudly in any part of kashmir same words….u bark in secure areas hv u guts to repeate it downtown srinigar tral….. pulwama …and palhalan …

    Reply
  6. awsm post….. respect to each wrds….

    Reply
  7. First IIM..then writer…then a Dance show judge..now you are trying to become a politician….hahaaa #Lol….
    Let me tell you one thing. Is this thd future of kashmiri youths with india, that a young cricketer is being killed by army…
    An 11th class student is being targeted with bullets…..their are lakhs of incidents like this…and you are talking about future……
    If this is the future with india then we spit on this kind of future…..

    Reply
    • Bhai je asae bhot sae Cricketer puri staet main to etna zadha propogandakarnae ke zaroot nahi ha. Yae to wo he bat ho ge “ kese ke murgee truck mae neachae marge, to us kae malik nae bhola koe mujae 10 lakh chyae. Admi bhola bhai road is meant for driving it not for hens. To tum ko dhyan rakhna chyae tha” The owner of the hen replied , “mare murgee 4 KG ke the, es nae 10 saal jena tha, 10 sall main 50 egg danae tae, har egg main 5 rs ka bachta and so on. Mujae loss ko gya business main is lea i will charge 10 lakh”
      Cricketer tha India kae leyae khalna tha to Anti Indian protest main kya kara raha tha.
      Aur 11 class ka bacha protest main kya kar raha tha. Yae protest karna us ka kam nahi tha. Us kam kam panda tha apni koum ke traki tha, Mom dad ka Naam roshan karna tha.

      Reply
    • And you sad killing innocent muslims. kab kedher hotae ho ja kashmir main apnae he log terrorist ke goli aur blast main marae jatae ha. you are talking about Gujarat and you must know that most of the culprits brought to Justis and are in jail. and yes what about Kashmiri pandits, what about the roits of rajouri. bhai je there is a lot of difference in being Jihadist & terrorist.

      Reply
    • Goli he khaega porkistani suwar..porkistani infiltrator ho tum sab jihadi..abhi to sirf 5 kutte ki maut mare hai abi aage dekho kese tum jaise bastards ko crush karege..kashmir sirf hinduo ka h aur bharat ka hai..BHARAT MATA KI JAI..VANDE MATRAM..kaan khol ke sun le

      Reply
    • if u think by pelting stones on others they will greet u with flowers then go and wash ur face and think twice and thrice….

      Reply
    • Thinking needs brain and their brains are controlled by Hurriyat.

      Reply
    • You spit upon yourself brother.
      You see everything through the eye of your religion.
      That’s not your problem.

      Reply
    • what young cricketer or terrorist whatever you say was doing near army post with the people who were pelting stones on army. i think kshmiri have lost their senses they think after pelting stone, Army should give them flowers.

      Reply
    • Kashmir casts a long shadow over entire South Asia (SAARC).
      SAARC can realise its full potential if Kashmir issue is resolved. However, Pakistan must NOT raise Kashmir issue at SAARC, nor use SAARC merely as a platform for this purpose.
      Listen to the voice of 1.7 billion people of South Asia: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8mntcPFwwh0
      (You might also like: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CY7QG_8dgzs )

      Reply
    • chetan bhagat is a skilled writer i believe he understands the power of a good fiction book. when your whole world view is based on narrow minded books, you will surely have problems. lots of problems. i for one don’t want another fundamentalist run republic near my state. we have had enough.

      Reply
    • Bramhastra

      You can spit all you want on what-ever you want… but this is what YOU invited when you started the terrorism after colluding with Pakistan. YOU started the killing spree by murdering innocent people. Do you think everyone else including military should have just watched and let it continue? I still remember those words of muslims in the valley.. “Kashmir Banega Pakistan with Hindu women and without Hindu women”.. that shows who you really are… a terrorist. When there is no difference between a terrorist and a normal population… everyone dies… so don’t give these sob stories of 11th grade student. They are the ones who throw stones on army when they fight against terrorists… they are the ones who throw stones at helicopters that are rescuing people in flood. Are you also willing to stop eating the subsidized food, getting subsidized education.. also those good for nothing kashmiri muslims who never go to work and simply collect their salary at the end of the month?
      —————————
      Remind the world who Sikandar Butshikan was and what he did to the original settlers of Kashmir.. There was NOT a single Muslim there. He murdered, pillaged, killed and converted with wanton… but muslims being muslims quickly forget that… Remind the world what YOU did to the remaining sikhs and Hindus? Now you claim that land is yours? really? It was never yours… Invaders will always be invaders.. it does not matter when they came.

      Reply
  8. First get the facts right then talk about Kashmir .then send a letter to Kashmir ..being so knowledgeable you r too weak when it comes to Kashmir ….you don’t have even 0% knowledge about Kashmir

    Reply
  9. my only question to chetan ji y did rohith vemulas brother and mother got converted to buddisim….

    Reply
  10. This page is functioning by Jammu police, so plz guys don’t be panic, let them bark, it is frustration their and nothing, otherwise they know it well what will gonna happen with India..

    Reply
  11. Sir,,, thanks for ur nice words and advice,,but it is quite sure many of kashmiri brothers are not going to ponder upon ur views,,,instead there will be lots of abusing,,use of foul language ,cursing u and ur family,,,calling by names Endians ka chamcha and in last they will (whose ancestors were pundits)brand u as a sanghi,, brahmin and even kafir…..That’s the new face of kashmiriyat and the hospitality…..

    Reply
  12. Dear Kashmir’s story is very different, it is the story which erects on 1947 and Indian politics sustained only on the innocent blood of Kashmiri’s how they feel ease to let us make the decision suitable for us.

    Reply
  13. Azadi to Allah inko rog de reha hai

    Reply
  14. What u hv expressed ,what u predicted and what u suggested ..keeping all these on a round with hight lower than when I sit on the chair with 4 legs u r I am to say u r emotional and u see things on ur own side of ur domain of thinking with ur range zero…..u need to get ur self in the positive direction…..

    Reply
  15. pather ka jabab goli se degai hum ……..all the best ……………

    Reply
  16. What youth…… they aer robots in the hands of Huryat.

    Reply
  17. Go to hell…chetan…..Who r u to give us suggestions…..u an idiot writer

    Reply
  18. India is a poor country with beggars and biharis..like chetan chamcha

    Reply
  19. kashmiris ko jitna smjao ge yeh smjne wale nhi hai vo kehte hai na bansh k aage bean bjana aur yeh log vo hai jo laaton k booht baathon se nhi maante kyu ki inka dimag mota hai aur mota he rahega mota mass khane ki bjha se….foolish people.

    Reply
  20. Shabir Ahmad

    The writer is quite ignorant or pretends to be so because of his open affiliation with Hindutua forces. He has unsuccessfully tried to exaggerate the historical facts about Kashmir. Indians have a long history of lies and distorting the history especially when it comes to Muslim history.The largest proof of their lies and falsehood is we Kashmiris,before our open eyes they negate the facts happened.It would be better if the author comes for an one on one debate to have it on floor and lets find a solution to the problem.

    Reply
    • U people are just disgusting….@Chetan bhagat sir stop writing these articles they are of no use because these morons will never understand

      Reply
      • Mohsin Chisti

        Ma’am, you think mr Bhagat Singh , was a moron too who fought for independence ? Just leave us alone . Stop torturing us with your words and bullets!

        Reply
  21. Salute to Chetan Sir…

    Reallity always.Speaks.truth and undoubtedly we knw Good ppls accept but how come.we think brutal will accept the Truth Statement.. Jai Hind…

    Reply
  22. Written as a patriotic endian, few words used by the author have messed it up. Like Islamic fundamentalist, terrorism, economy. If u really care about Kashmir or Kashmiri ppl u can help even after our Independence like Bangladesh and Nepal, v can hv a tourism like Monaco and generate electricity for our economy to thrive, only if u remain unselfish or no enemy. U r using religion as issue for separation then it is caused by a Hindu maharaja not a Muslim King. Their r many other things that author should look onto persuade Kashmiri youth cos v hv lost much more than u think, to change our sentiments, which right now seems v difficult.

    Reply
    • LiveinPeace

      do you have any idea about hindu sentiment for all genocide by your ancestors? where were kashmiri muslims 500 years back?
      you are ok with hindu genocide by radical invaders and off – late genocide of kashmiri hindus, thats ok for you. what double standards you have???

      Reply
  23. I hereby request to mr. admin of this page, kick out every jihadi out of this page like our army is kicking them out..BHARAT MATA KI JAI

    Reply
  24. Inhe kisne bnaya kashmiri, ye saare ke saare porkistani infiltrator h ya fir wo h jo forcefully muslim bna diye gaye..i just spit on their nijam-e-mustafa go to hell..kashmir sirf hinduo ka tha aur rahega!..BHARAT MATA KI JAI

    Reply
  25. Bakht’s feeling happy .. Now read the below response & sink your happiness in shame.

    Open letter to #ChetanBhagat from a Kashmiri, bursting Bhagat’s bubbles. A fool in a population of billion is not a surprise. http://www.dailyo.in/politics/jammu-and-kashmir-handwara-killings-indian-army-afspa-kashmiri-freedom-struggle-rape-kunan-poshpora-shopian/story/1/10125.html

    #Kashmir #HandwaraKillings #IOK

    Reply
  26. Anzar koka

    Mr Bagat believe it or not, out of 7 million Kashmiris more than a million people can write better than your good selling books , had Kashmir not been under Indian occupation. We still can but you guys won’t let us.
    Who do you think, you are adressing. We very well know, what to do.

    Reply
  27. Dr Shoukat Khan

    Chetan your write up has all the ingredients of a best seller paperback. Reminds me of your magnum opus ” One night at call centre ” India has failed to create a feeling of integration among common Kashmiris. Our most secular and India loving leader Sheikh Abdullah was imprisoned by a paranoid Prime Minister of India. The grandson of that paranoid PM together with one of the CM of Kashmir rigged the popular elections which was the start of separatism. Our children are beaten up in institutions of other parts of the country. Our women have been raped and we hardly see any coviction of the accused. Go through the details in a book on ” Kunanposhpora rapes”. Our unemployed children have been shot to death for protesting against human rights violations. There are thousands who have simply disappeared. We have one of the highest unemployment rates in the country. We reposef our faith in Indian democracy and got in return puppet governance through elections rigged at behest of Indias intelligence. The problem of Kashmir has nothing to do with area of J&K its about the majority population and their political, social, economical and cultural aspirations. Indian democracy is a victim of its feudal character that is creating inequality, intolerance and injustice. How does a community express its political , social, economical and cultural aspirations if you take away all the space. They pelt stones, burst crackers and prefer taking bullets to avoid a life of perpetual humiliation and subjugation. Let India own Kashmiris in letter and spirit first may be things change. Mr Chetan Bhagat i like you as a writer of fiction and surrealism but reality in life is a different ball game.

    Reply
    • Vishesh Gautam

      Dr Shoukat Khan sir,

      Greetings. I can somehow agree with you when you say that Chetan Bhagat has no idea about the various pressures, atrocities and the dangers an average Kashmiri experiences under the governance of Indian Army, the JK Govt, the Indian intelligence and the Central Govt. because after all it is the air inside a vessel on fire that knows about the heat, not the air outside the vessel. Still, I can’t believe any argument that Kashmir, if separated from India, would fare better. Therefore, I would like to interact with you personally via mail, to know about your views, your opinions, your knowledge of Kashmir that eludes the Indian populations at large and I would like to know, whether if it is possible by you, that if you were to accept the removal of Article 370 from the Indian Constitution and a complete unification with India, in spirit and territory, what would be your first expectations and aspirations from yourself as well as the Govt of India ? then what would be your aspirations and expectations from the current youth of Kashmir and the people outside Kashmir ? And finally the generations that have yet to come ? Is there a medial path that we can walk together or is there always going to be this confrontational path that ends with one hand tearing apart at a wound on the other hand ? I will patiently await your reply at darklord171@gmail.com

      Reply
  28. Mohsin Chisti

    Mr Bhagat, I pity your arrogance and ignorance. Just keep your writings for your fantasy novels. We don’t need your letters . We have enough distress and dispair. Just leave us alone! Please.

    Reply
  29. Bakhta feeling happy .. Now read the below response & sink your happiness in shame.

    Open letter to #ChetanBhagat from a Kashmiri, bursting Bhagat’s bubbles. A fool in a population of billion is not a surprise. http://www.dailyo.in/politics/jammu-and-kashmir-handwara-killings-indian-army-afspa-kashmiri-freedom-struggle-rape-kunan-poshpora-shopian/story/1/10125.html

    #Kashmir #HandwaraKillings #IOK

    Reply
    • LiveinPeace

      ha ha

      you are taking a reference of a website which is not an authenticate source of information. Even I can build a website and write all bullshit about kashmiri muslims. I will not do that because I treat them as my own people. You dont believe girls version where she clearly tells that she was molested by 2 local people. Why shud she lie as that cud be a blow to army? why dont you thing twice to see whether she is genuine. You believe people who want to create problem in valley in the name of islam and not the poor innocent girl. what kind of justice are you talking about?

      Reply
  30. Half of your country poops on railway tracks,u bettr do somethn fo them ist.. lol

    Reply
  31. He{chetan bhagat} does not know that the kashmiri loves pakistan and its militant group and there Shari’a law’s, thats why kashmiri muslims kick out kashmiri pandits from valley,he should b apologize…

    Reply
  32. “बेरोजगारी हटाओ अभियान”

    चैंपियन नेटवर्कस प्राइवेट लिमिटेड कंपनी में 10000 ऐसे लड़के / लड़कियों की जरुरत है जो घर बैठे ही अपने Android फोन से ऑनलाइन वर्क कर सकें , काम सिर्फ फेसबुक और व्हाट्सएप्प पर ऐड पोस्टिंग का है।

    जितनी ज्यादा मेहनत उतनी ज्यादा इनकम कर सकते है बिना कुछ इन्वेस्टमेंट किये।

    कंपनी का उद्देश्य पैसा कमाना नहीं बल्कि भारत से बेरोजगारी को दूर करना है।

    इछुक व्यक्ति टाइप कीजिये Join और भेज दें हमारे Whtsapp नंबर 9501728260 पर।

    नोट:- कृपया वही लोग संपर्क करें जो मेहनत कर के कुछ पाना चाहते हैं, बिना कुछ किये पाने की इच्छा रखने वाले हमसे संपर्क न करें।

    Reply
  33. ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ..!!!

    Reply
  34. painful kashmir

    Mr Bhagat sir,, i am quite surprised about your opinion to our Kashmir i request you sir let us live our life please don’t try make your Bread..

    Reply
  35. Kashmir has more freedom than any other state of India. And that is enough.
    Islam is no issue at all .
    Those who are radicalized by pakistani agents and hope that they will be successful in their designs shall bring only misfortunes .

    Reply
  36. Yahi agar hamari jagah Israel hota toh kabka kashmir issue solve hogya hota. Aur Kashmir kya…woh toh aadhe pakistan ko bhi India bna diye hote hahaha 😉

    Reply
  37. because something terrible is happening in the Kashmir Valley The recent events at NIT Srinagar only brought the situation to national attention,
    National Attention, What do You Mean by National Attention? You Scared us Oooh Bhagat Ji We Kashmiri are not Scared With Your Articles , We Have Already keep our steps in battle ground We will Never See Back We dont care…..

    Reply
  38. are u talking abt the indian army that has been raping and killing kashmiris since last 3 decades, army that kills protesters by firing in the head, kills people in fake encounters and molests and rapes at gun point,,, wake up indians, ur soldiers have committed war crimes in kashmir, and ur media has never told u the truth abt kashmir …

    Reply
  39. I’m sure everyone feels like ‘Why a writer who claims to be fiction story expert, speak on such violations’ But — At the end, he is a writer and he speaks his mind. The writer tries to explain ‘Kashmir should join India for a better future’ – That’s it, In the entire post, He shows the caring for the People of Kashmir by expressing ‘Rather than fighting – Be Greedy for your Future’

    I was going through everyone’s comments & failed completely to understand ‘ Why are we talking so negative ‘ – I’ve never been to Kashmir & Hope to visit the valley, also likes to point out one important thing — I as an Indian have always taken J&K as part of India & always prayed for all the people living over there. Dr Shoukat explains the propaganda — But, For a common man, I have no idea what that is, perhaps a little more information about it will surely do some justice to everyone reading this post. What Indian Kashmiri really wants ??
    I should also highlight things which are going wrong in Kashmir – Whether it’s about Indian army or injustice with Indian Kashmiri people — But, Should we not let’s find the solution rather than cursing the writer. I haven’t find a single post wherein someone tries to explain the reason ‘What Kashmir really wants ? – Do they wants to be left alone | Go with Pakistan.
    If left alone, How will you survive – Hunt animals or Farming, What about communication equipments, Education, Natural Calamities, I mean there is lot of picture we are missing. If you want to join ‘Pakistan’ – Now let’s access the suggestion with Pakistan — Terrorist, Zero education, No right to speak, No women empowerment, Rapes and everything that goes wrong for a country.

    ——- At the end, I would really like to hear a genuine perspective for ‘ What Kashmir really wants ?’

    Reply
  40. NOW USE WWW, TRYLIKER ,COM AND GET DAILY 5000 LIKES ON FACEBOOK ^_^

    Reply
  41. no respect for believers in fictional nonsense on either side. this whole conflict is driven by religious hatred. do want justice for all victims, but not another islamic nation in our neighborhood. wake up sheeple there are a lot of interesting books to read out there

    Reply
  42. abe bc yeh pen aur paper wala kam nhi h….if u realy care abt the kashmiri youth then come here and spend near about 2 months with us just like a citizen of kashmir not as a tourist …after that give ur statement …

    Reply
  43. First of Fall Not only #India,#Pakistan Dis #World Blongs to Rich,Politicians & Dheir Chemchaas #Brahmins

    Reply
  44. Pfokrelo Kapesa

    Dear Chetan, I know you are stupid and you won’t understand the Kashmir issue so don’t try,. By the way there are many people who wants to read your stupid books so continue with that and don’t try to understand things or comment about them when it is beyond the ability of the coconut on your shoulder because you may end up puking

    Reply
  45. LiveinPeace

    Dear Kashmiri brothers and sisters,

    Ask one simple question about your origin. Your ancestors invaded India in a barbaric way killing Hindus, Buddhists and slowly become majority in the valley. Are you not shameful to claim the land which is not yours. Kashmir has got thousands of year history including that of sage kashyapa from him the name kashmir is inspired with. The real oppression has happened by you people who are outsiders. I think if you want azadi from us then better test your DNA and go to your country of origin and live peacefully with taliban/IS/Al-qaeda. Please leave us to live in peace or else be one among us without cribbing in the name of ISLAM. As chetan pointed out rightly, your future is bright with India and not with Pakistan. If at all you go with Pakistan you will become something lile earlier Bangaldesh or Balochistan. Please pakistanis will not give you special treatment. think if you can…..

    Also it shows your ill mindset about army which rescued some many people during floods without giving first priority to their family. This shows you dont have courtesy to acknowledge someone who helped you. Actually you are not real followers of Islam, I don’t many of you not following it in right spirit. So in nutshell you have 2 options, one to be with India in peaceful way or go back to origin country (afganistand/iran/turkey)…decide yourself.

    Reply

Leave a Comment