JK Govt opposes Central Selection Mechanism for appointments in Subordinate Judiciary

SRINAGAR, AUGUST 23: Jammu and Kashmir government has opposed the Centralized Selection Mechanism (CSM) for appointments in the subordinate judiciary citing the reason that the state enjoys special status under the constitution of India.

Pertinently, the Supreme Court of India had sent a concept note to all the states with a proposal for a Centralized Selection Mechanism for appointment of Judicial Officers in the subordinate courts of the states and had sought suggestions from all the states.

Since the case involved the interpretation of the constitution, J&K Government hired the services of Rakesh Dwivedi, Senior Advocate in addition to Shoeb Alam, Advocate on record to defend the State.

The State Government filed a detailed affidavit highlighting the constitutional peculiarity before the Apex Court.

The counsels appearing on behalf of Jammu and Kashmir submitted before the apex court that the special constitutional position of J&K state in the Constitution of India  makes it clear that centralizing the selection process for appointment of District Judges won’t be in consonance with the constitutional position enjoyed by the state of J&K as the power to appoint District Judges is with the Governor of the State in consultation with the State High Court as per Section-109 of the Constitution of J&K that is different from other states of the country where appointments are being made under Article 233 of the Constitution of India.

“Appointment of District Judges is a Constitutional power vested with the Governor to be exercised in consultation with the State High Court. Thus this power cannot be taken away or abridged by exercise of judicial powers by court,” the J&K counsel argued.

JK government said the High Court in J&K exercises greater independence than the High Courts of other states as the entire state judiciary including the High Court and the subordinate courts are not constituted under the Constitution of India but under the constitution of J&K and the appointment of judges of the JK High Court and District Judges takes place under the constitution of J&K.

No: PR/DI/17/4643/

Download the U4UVoice App Now:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *